11/15/12

Pechanga to Purchase Land from Granite Construction

http://temecula.patch.com/articles/pechanga-tribe-to-purchase-liberty-quarry-land

RivCo Supes: Liberty Quarry hearing tentatively set for Dec. 11

RivCo Supes: Liberty Quarry hearing tentatively set for Dec. 11 By Kerri S. Mabee, With the rousing 2012 Election season winding down to little more than a quiet hum, an epic battle continues to brew over the proposed Liberty Quarry in Temecula. The debate surrounding the Liberty Quarry has been a years-long battle for city officials and residents. (Credit: bidgee/Wikimedia Commons) After a divided Riverside County Board of Supervisors elected to allow a fast-track review of the controversial mining project despite two recent lawsuits filed against the county, Temecula city officials and residents are gearing up for a hearing tentatively scheduled for Dec. 11 that could spur the project into motion. Read: City of Temecula speaks out against 'fast-tracking' against controversial quarry Temecula Mayor Chuck Washington has vigorously opposed the mining project and vowed to see its demise, despite Granite Construction's re-vamped proposal that would mean a smaller scale version of the original Liberty Quarry. "We still have lots of kick still in us. I have no doubt in my mind that I can speak for my city council colleagues when I say we will fight this," Washington told SWRNN previously. Washington is joined by Temecula City Mayor Pro Tem Mike Nagger who has promised a stalwart defense of outside forces that are trying to bring the Liberty Quarry to Temecula. "What (Granite Construction) wants to do is to destroy one of our most pristine environments," Naggar said, adding that the threat to Temecula's way of life might necessitate that the city finds a way to purchase the land. The debate surrounding the Liberty Quarry has been a years-long battle for city officials and residents. Despite Granite Construction's promise of jobs, the controversial Liberty Quarry project has long drawn stiff opposition from Temecula city council members, Pechanga tribal leaders, and local groups who reject the idea of a rock quarry clouding up Temecula's picturesque hills. The original Liberty Quarry was voted down with the Riverside County Board of Supervisors' 3-2 vote against the proposed mining project on Feb. 16, 2012. But, the victory was short-lived. In May, a divided Riverside County Board of Supervisors moved to certify an environmental impact report for the strip mine near Temecula, drawing sharp criticism from those opposed to the project and opening the door to a "fast-track" proposal that has been debated at the Riverside County Board of Supervisors. The Riverside County Board of Supervisors will consider the fast-track in a meeting tentatively scheduled at 9 a.m. on Dec. 11 in the Board of Supervisors chambers on the first floor, 4080 Lemon St. in Riverside.

11/14/12

Rainbow Planning Group - Agenda - 11-14-12

A San Diego County Heritage Community Since 1880 Keeping Rainbow Rural Advising the Board of Supervisors ~ San Diego County Notice of Meeting Wednesday, November 14, 2012 at 7:00 PM at the Rainbow Grange If there are any changes an updated version will be posted at the Grange Hall at least 72 hours prior to this meeting. I. Call to order and Pledge Allegiance – Dennis A. Sanford, Chairperson II. Call for a Quorum III. Approval of Previous Regular Meeting Minutes IV. Open Forum: Opportunity for the public to speak on items not on the agenda. Each speaker is limited to 5 minutes. Speakers should address community land use issues. V. Committee Comments: Comments are limited to the parameters of the Brown Act. VI. County Action Items: • Correspondence a. None of significance to Rainbow • Board of Supervisors Actions a. None of significance to Rainbow VII. Old Business and Reports • I-15 Advisory Committee status report • Pala Raceway noise pollution status report- Swanson • Draft letter to track sponsors • Playground and Park cover grant status report- Bonner • Request for signage at Rice Canyon/Rainbow Heights status report- Bonner • Liberty Quarry Status Update VIII. New Business • Officers for 2013 • Status of LED billboard signage • Vacant seats on committee IX. Call for January 16, 2013 agenda items X. Adjournment until January 16, 2013

11/7/12

Temecula: Liberty Quarry granted 'fast-track,' RivCo Supes divided

A sharply divided Riverside County Board of Supervisors today granted a fast-track review of a proposed mining project near Temecula abhorred by a large number of residents and the trigger for two recent lawsuits filed against the county.
(Greg Goebel/Flickr) "This is preposterous and reeks of bad government," Temecula City Councilman Mike Naggar told the board before its 3-2 vote to expedite scrutiny of the controversial Liberty Quarry. "When did we start fast-tracking surface mines? It's on par with fast-tracking a nuclear power plant .," Naggar said. "People are seeing this and believing this is the worst in government." Several dozen speakers lashed out at the board for taking action in favor of the quarry, while less than a dozen lauded Supervisors John Benoit, Marion Ashley and John Tavaglione for giving the project new life. "This is a good project made better thanks to its reduced size and impacts," said Granite Construction Resource Manager Gary Johnson. Watsonville-based Granite first sought fast-track processing for the quarry in July, but the county did not then have provisions in place for accelerating reviews of proposed mines. In a 3-2 vote in February, the board rejected the 414-acre quarry. However, about three months later, in another 3-2 vote, the board certified a 1,000-page environmental impact report that found many of the project's negative impacts could be mitigated. That opened the door to Granite returning with a scaled-down mining proposal, which it did. Last month, following several heated public hearings, the board voted 3- 2 to implement amendments to county ordinances allowing mining operations to receive fast-track authorization. The goal is to have projects vetted and voted on by the board in 90 days. Benoit and Ashley have been steadfast supporters of the quarry, while Supervisors Jeff Stone and Bob Buster have staunchly opposed it. Chairman Tavaglione was the swing voter against the project in February, but voted to certify the EIR and has voted with Ashley and Benoit ever since. The Riverside native is running for a congressional seat and widely expected to win. Quarry opponents insist the pit will produce health-damaging levels of silica dust, mar area aesthetics, ruin rural peace, add to road congestion and permanently alter landscapes that the Pechanga Band of Luiseno Indians consider sacred. "You are fast-tracking the destruction of the southern gateway to Riverside County," mine opponent and Temecula City Council candidate Paul Jacobs told the board. "You are fast-tracking disrespect for the creation site of the Pechanga tribe. Your contempt for all the people of southwest Riverside County is on display here today." Several speakers leveled criticism directly at Benoit, who introduced the proposal to fast-track Liberty Quarry and has sponsored each effort to move the proposal forward since July. "You should've stayed in Sacramento because this board has become as dysfunctional as state government," Norco resident Julie Waltz told the former state lawmaker. Stone, whose district encompasses Temecula, reiterated the threat he believes the quarry poses to local vineyards and "wine country" tourism in general. "This has been the most divisive issue I've witnessed on the board," Stone said. "It's very unfortunate someone other than the supervisor in whose district the project will reside can be bold enough to put this on a fast track. You're fast-tracking an open pit mine that will unearth eight rose bowls. This is not about jobs. This is about money." Benoit, who has characterized Granite as a "friend" to the Coachella Valley, denied that the revenue generation potential for the county influenced him in any way. "There is a cost to moving granite," Benoit said. "For every mile that it's transported, the cost goes up. That's extra costs to taxpayers for projects built in this area. Every extra mile that it's transported also means more air pollution. There are regional benefits to having this mine." "That's a bunch of malarkey," Stone retorted. "By Granite's own admission, 70 percent of the product from this mine will go to San Diego County. It's so transparent what's happening here. I'm embarrassed." According to Granite, its modified mine plan calls for restricting operations to daylight hours, with 160 fewer truck trips planned to and from the site daily. The amount of product mined at the location will be slashed 25 percent, or by 61 million tons, and the mining depth will be limited to 300 feet. Granite also touted the estimated $92 million in new revenue that will accrue to the county from the project, thanks largely to tonnage fees charged to customers. The quarry would lie just off Interstate 15 at Rainbow Valley Rd. Temecula filed a lawsuit in July challenging the validity of the EIR. On Oct. 10, it filed another suit seeking a reversal of the board's amendments to county law permitting accelerated reviews of proposed strip mines, alleging the board behaved "prejudicially" by not giving the planning commission an opportunity to review the fast-track proposal.

11/4/12

TEMECULA: City seeking Liberty Quarry-related restraining order


TEMECULA: City seeking Liberty Quarry-related restraining order
Temecula will file the request the day before supervisors consider fast-tracking the Liberty Quarry project
Temecula is expected to file for a restraining order against Riverside County on Monday, Nov. 5 - a day before the County Board of Supervisors is scheduled to consider fast tracking the controversial Liberty Quarry project.
The restraining order would block the board from acting on a request from Supervisor John Benoit to speed up the revised Liberty Quarry plan, which would allow the project to skip the Planning Commission and go straight to supervisors for a decision. The proposal is set to be discussed during a 9 a.m. Nov. 6 hearing in Riverside.
Temecula City Attorney Peter Thorson said Friday the city is seeking an order that prohibits the county from making a decision on the Liberty Quarry proposal until after a ruling is rendered in the city's lawsuit over the project. That suit challenges the ordinances altering the fast-track process to include surface mines among the list of projects that are moved quickly through the county approval process.
"Our lawsuit states that these ordinances were illegally adopted," Thorson said. "The board failed to adopt a proper (environmental) exemption, failed to obtain approval from the State Board of Mines and Geology and failed to obtain planning commission review of the ordinances."
The lawsuit was filed in mid-October, and is the second lawsuit filed by the city against the county with regard to the proposed quarry. A first lawsuit was filed in late July opposing supervisors' approval of the environmental document detailing how a quarry would affect the surrounding environment. A hearing on that first lawsuit is scheduled for Nov. 14.
If the restraining order is denied, however, supervisors could approve the fast-track changes, paving the way for Granite Construction to move forward with its revised application for the quarry south of Temecula.
Derek Cole, an attorney representing Riverside County, said Friday that the county will challenge the request for the restraining order.
"The city has not yet served its moving papers in support of the (restraining order) yet," Cole said, referring to the paperwork that must be delivered to the other parties in such a case. "For that reason, we haven't submitted anything to the court either. Assuming I receive the city's moving papers sometime today, I will have the county's opposition ready by first thing Monday morning, when I will submit that to the court."
The proposed Liberty Quarry has been a divisive issue in the county.
Supervisors in May upheld a planning commission decision denying the project while still certifying the environmental report.
Following the project denial, Granite Construction resubmitted plans for a scaled-down version on the same 414-acre site in between Temecula and the San DiegoCounty line. The revised mine, according to Granite, would have a 50-year instead of a 75-year life span. The quarry would aim to produce 174 million tons of aggregate over its lifetime rather than the 235 million tons originally proposed.
In addition, the new quarry would generate a maximum of 640 truck trips a day, down from 800 trips in the old version, Granite contends. The mine pit would be 710 feet at its deepest point - the old version dug more than 1,000 feet in the ground - and annual aggregate production would be 1 million fewer tons a year, according to Granite.
Granite also has proposed a 20-cent-per-ton tipping fee it says will generate $92 million in revenue for Riverside County. Nearly $62 million of that will come from San Diego County users, the company said.

11/2/12

Benoit urges fast track for quarry



 

Never-ending battle goes on: Benoit urges fast track for quarry

Benoit proposes putting Liberty Quarry on fast track. Supervisor asks that revised Liberty Quarry proposal review skip Planning Commission
As expected, a Riverside County supervisor from Palm Springs has formally proposed accelerating county review of Granite Construction’s scaled-down Liberty Quarry project on Temecula’s outskirts.
Supervisor John Benoit’s request will be taken up Tuesday by the Board of Supervisors in Riverside.
“This revised project will further reduce truck trips, associated pollution and degradation of roads throughout much of Riverside County,” Benoit stated in a written report to the board. “Additionally, it will create more than 75 new, permanent, fulltime jobs; invest more than $10 million in land, building and equipment; and generate more than $25 million in taxable sales annually.”
Opponents were anticipating a return of the emotionally charged issue in early November.
“It was not a surprise to us,” said Fred Bartz, board member for the Save Our Southwest Hills environmental group. “The never-ending battle goes on.”
Approval of Benoit’s initiative is anticipated.
In a series of votes setting the stage for his request, the board consistently voted 3-2 to approve preliminary steps to order an ordinance making quarries eligible for fast-track review and then to adopt that ordinance. Approval could deliver a board vote on Liberty Quarry within three months.
“It means the project goes through the rest of the (environmental) review process that it would normally go through without having to go through the Planning Commmission,” county spokesman Ray Smith said.
Besides bypassing the commission, fast-track approval would give the county 90 days to complete its review and bring the item back to the board, Smith said.
After numerous lengthy hearings, the Riverside County Planning Commission rejected Granite’s project 4-1 last year. Supervisors followed that up with a narrow 3-2 rejection in February.
But the trail took a sharp turn in May, when supervisors voted 3-2 to certify Granite’s environmental impact report. That report was approved when Supervisor John Tavaglione, who had voted to reject the quarry and who is running for Congress, joined two supporters: Benoit and Supervisor Marion Ashley.
Supervisors Jeff Stone and Bob Buster continued to oppose the project.
Stone has characterized the fast-track march as a race against time — to put the revised Liberty Quarry up for a vote before Tavaglione leaves office — assuming he is elected next week to the House of Representatives from a new Riverside-Moreno Valley district.
The thinking is that Democratic Gov. Jerry Brown, the one charged with filling a board vacancy, would appoint a more liberal supervisor who would be sensitive to environmental issues and vote to kill the project.
What supervisors originally killed in February was a proposed aggregate mine on 135 acres south of Temecula in the rugged hills west of Interstate 15 that was to harvest 5 million tons of rock annually for 75 years.
However, under county rules, a company may resubmit plans by changing a project’s scale. Granite exercised that option in July, submitting a plan for a “new” project to mine up to 4 million tons a year instead of 5 million, and quit after 50 years instead of 75.
Granite Construction also threw in a sweetener: a fee paid to the county based on the amount mined.
First unveiled in 2005, the mine is one of the most controversial issues ever to rock Southwest County.
Opponents contend that dust from the mining operation would harm human health and mar mountain views, that trucks hauling aggregate would snarl traffic on Interstate 15, that the mine would foul a site sacred to the Pechanga Band of Luiseno Indians, and that its presence would spoil Temecula’s tourism industry.
Supporters contend the mine actually would deliver cleaner air, because there would be tight controls on dust and fewer trucks traveling through Southwest County. Their argument cites forecasts that most of the aggregate would be trucked south to San Diego County. Because the mine’s presence would reduce the need to import rock from farther north, such as Corona-area quarries, the region’s gravel-carrying trucks would kick up less pollution.
Proponents, including Benoit, also maintain the project would create badly needed jobs for a county with a high unemployment rate.
Bartz begs to differ.
Quoting testimony from an earlier hearing, Bartz said, “Approving additional quarry sites does not bring jobs — demand brings jobs. I think the jobs issue is without merit.”

10/26/12

Asphalt Tar Spill Fouls 'pretty special creek'!


Sandia Creek runs through a good portion of San Diego County (Fallbrook)
as well as Riverside County.
Multiply the chances of this happening again by hundreds (1600 truck trips
per day) if Liberty quarry is approved.
Jerri

PRESS ENTERPRISE    October 26, 2012
BY SARAH BURGE    sburge@pe.com
DE LUZ: Asphalt tar spill fouls 'pretty special creek'
SARAH BURGE/STAFF PHOTO
A cleanup crew works Wednesday, Oct. 24, to remove asphalt tar that fouled a
stretch of Sandia Creek in the rural De Luz area west of Temecula.
Hundreds of gallons of asphalt tar that spilled from an overturned truck this week in the rural De Luz area west of Temecula flowed into the pristine Sandia Creek and cleanup of the mucky mess is expected to take days, authorities said.
A petroleum scent hung in the air around the creek Wednesday, Oct. 24, as crews in hazmat suits shoveled contaminated soil into buckets and pumped water flowing from upstream around the spill area blocked with containment booms. The asphalt tar - a heavy, sticky petroleum product - coated vegetation and sank to the bottom of the creek.
The California Department of Fish and Game is overseeing the cleanup, which is being performed by a private contractor hired by the asphalt company that caused the spill. A Fish and Game news release described Sandia Creek as one of the last pristine, free-flowing creeks in Southern California.


"This is a pretty special creek for Southern California," said Lt. Michael Horn, the incident commander for Fish and Game. "It has really nice habitat in it and it does maintain a year-round flow."
"This is actually a tributary to the Santa Margarita River, which runs to the Pacific Ocean," Horn said. "But we're a substantial distance from the river."
Horn said about 600 gallons of the tar spilled but it's unclear how much flowed into the creek. Authorities said initially that the spill had been contained to a 300-yard stretch, but Horn said water flowing through the site had spread some of the oily substance farther downstream. Biologists are investigating possible effects on wildlife, he said.
Luckily, Horn said, the creek flow has been low so the spill has been largely contained.
Crews have not found any sensitive species harmed by the spill, but a tree frog and 16 mosquito fish were found dead, officials said.
Janna Rinderneck and Daniel Orr, environmental scientists with the Department of Fish and Game, said the creek is home to species of concern such as the coastal range newt and the arroyo chub. It also lies within the range of the arroyo toad, a federally listed endangered species, Orr said.
The spill happened about 12:30 p.m. Monday when a truck overturned along De Luz Road near Sandia Creek, said California Highway Patrol Officer Nathan Baer. The driver took a turn too fast, Baer said, and the load of water, sand and asphalt tar oil in the truck shifted.
The asphalt tar flowed out of the tanker, along the roadside and into the creek several yards away.
"It just got worse and worse," Baer said.
The name of the driver and the asphalt company were not available Wednesday, Baer said.

Second Suit to Stop Fast-Tracking


Second suit to stop fast-tracking

Wearing their trademark orange and waving orange hats, Liberty Quarry opponents attend a Riverside County Board
of Supervisors hearing on the project. A fourth quarry-related lawsuit seeks to stop the county from putting the
 project on the planning fast track.
 
 
Another lawsuit has been filed to stop Riverside County from speeding up the review process for surface mines such as the proposed Liberty Quarry.
The suit filed in Riverside Superior Court on Tuesday, Oct. 23, by Save Our Southwest Hills is the fourth legal action regarding the quarry. The citizens group, a leading voice in the quarry opposition movement, is a plaintiff in another quarry-related case, and the city of Temecula has filed two quarry-related suits as well.
The latest suit seeks to overturn the county Board of Supervisors' September decision to add surface mines to the list of projects eligible for fast-tracking, which allows projects to skip the Planning Commission and go straight to the board for approval.
The change could lead to quicker action on the quarry sought for a 414-acre site bordering Temecula. Quarry developer Granite Construction submitted a revised quarry application this summer after supervisors voted 3-2 in May to reject the original proposal.
The suit alleges the county violated the California Environmental Quality Act by saying the fast-track changes were exempt from the act without supporting the exemption through adequate study.
The county also ran afoul of state law and its own land-use ordinance when it failed to have the Planning Commission hold a public hearing on the changes, the suit alleges. And the changes weren't brought to the State Mining & Geology Board for proper review, the suit argues.
County lawyers will review the suit once the county is served and "the county will determine the best course of response," county spokesman Ray Smith wrote in an email.
Earlier this month, Temecula officials filed their own fast-tracking suit. The suit makes similar arguments to the Save Our Southwest Hills litigation, and both plaintiffs want a restraining order blocking the county from using fast-tracking for surface mines.
Save Our Southwest Hills and Temecula also are parties in a separate legal action to de-certify the quarry's environmental impact report, an 8,500-page study paid for by Granite and reviewed by county planners that makes the case for the quarry.
County supervisors in May certified the report even though they denied the quarry. Granite and county lawyers contend the report's certification is legally justified.
The quarry is one of the most contentious land-use projects in county history. First proposed in 2005, the quarry would use explosive blasts to extract aggregate, a construction material consisting of tiny rocks. Asphalt and concrete would also be made on-site.
Granite and its supporters, including trade unions and business groups, say the quarry would support high-paying jobs, generate millions in taxes for the county and help the economy bounce back.
Temecula officials, environmentalists and others contend the quarry would devastate the Temecula Valley with air pollution, truck traffic and damage to a neighboring ecological reserve, among other harmful effects. The Pechanga Band of LuiseƱo Indians maintains the quarry would obliterate a sacred tribal site.

10/7/12

Wrong move on fast tracking


EDITORIAL: Wrong move on fast tracking

The decision by the Riverside County Board of Supervisors to gut its own project review process is unfortunate and should be reconsidered.
On Tuesday, the supervisors by a 3-2 vote authorized "fast track" review for mines, solar and wind power plants that would skip the county's Planning Commission.
Why?
Well, maybe it's because quarries and solar and wind power projects are so desperately needed that using the normal process is intolerable; but that assumption would be naive.
The move was made because a majority of the board doesn't want to hear the public howl.
The beneficiary is, of course, Granite Construction and its proposed Liberty Quarry.
That project, which had been the subject of years of controversy, was turned down in February ---- much to the cheers of local residents.
However, several maneuvers brought it back to life.
First, Supervisor John Tavaglione, who voted against the original project in February, surprisingly supported an after-the-fact approval of the quarry's environmental impact report in May.
Granite then returned to the game by revising its plans and scaling the project back slightly. It proposed to mine 4 million tons of rock a year instead of 5 million tons, over 50 years instead of 75.
Now Tavaglione, with Supervisors John Benoit and Marion Ashley, is poised to give Granite a break by not pushing the "new" proposal back to the Planning Commission, where public hearings would again provide an opportunity for the outraged citizenry to complain.
And opponents predict the majority will try to approve the quarry before Tavaglione leaves the board, assuming he is elected next month to a Riverside-area seat in Congress. It is anticipated he would be replaced by Democratic Gov. Jerry Brown with a more liberal supervisor who is more likely to oppose the project.
Adoption of a transparent planning process applicable to all who propose projects is a sensible way to govern.
Twisting the process to give special treatment to Granite does little but make residents view government as the captured interest of special interest. It creates cynicism and devalues the democracy.

Granite's certified EIR simply unjustified




The residents west of Granite's property start at 1,300 feet. After seven years of hearing "nothing lay to the west of the site" or the nearest community was two to three miles away, why does Granite's new application now admit there are residents west of the quarry site, though our valley wasn't considered in the certified environmental impact report?
Neither were the eight neighboring wells in our area that the valley relies on for water ---- and we're not the Rainbow Valley.
Granite told us our area's noise level already exceeds the county's noise standard (readings taken from a sound receptor three miles away) and that's why they need a "Noise Ordinance Exemption." Now the new application admits our area would be impacted by their noise. Hey, I thought the certified EIR had no faults.
We were told the quarry won't impact our water table (elevation 1,260 feet). Yet the new application decreased the pit down 700 feet, (elevation 1,310) drawing into question Granite's previous EIR statement. Leeching of contaminates will still enter our ground water and along our seasonal stream feeding local wells. Extensions can come later as did with Granite's Rosemary's Mountain recently to level the mountain, though it still sits idle.
The EIR's geological maps are incorrect, our valley is not of granite. It's porous and fractures easily.
Granite touted that the quarry would generate massive revenues for Riverside County. It was discovered the tax revenues would benefit San Diego. Something the Planning Commission hearings uncovered. So why didn't Granite offer Riverside County an added incentive of $0.20 a ton from the start? What false delusions are enticing the county?
Granite states the aggregate would be mainly for San Diego County, saving truck miles and improving air quality, yet they've shown an interest in the Highway 91 interchange project up north. Loaded trucks, headed north, chug, chug.
The vetting of Granite's first application took a long time, which is now an excuse used for fast tracking. If Granite didn't do such slipshod work, it would have saved time. It took the community to uncover the truth.
Yet, the Riverside County Planning Department found the 8,500-page EIR with not one thing wrong. The Planning Commission on the other hand thought it was biased and the benefits didn't outweigh the negative impacts.
With so many negative aspects of the project, why would Supervisors John Tavaglione, John Benoit and Marion Ashley be poised to fast track it to avoid doing the EIR correctly? Why would our public watchdogs be so quick to push the public away like a banana republic? The California Environmental Quality Act desires input from local residents to uncover any facts the bean counters missed.
It reminds me of that Allstate television commercial where the burglars throw "Mr. Mayhem," the watchdog, a huge bone to distract him, while the burglars ransack the house. The watchdog says, "Thanks guys, you're swell."
Granite's new application is proof that the certified EIR was flawed and unjustly certified. "Too many unknowns," as Tavaglione put it, before he flip-flopped.